I think there's no a lot of difference between new and old seller in Fiverr. If you are LUCKY, your gig will rank and you will get orders. I've been here for about 1 year, giving 6 GIGs. I have published every GIG with good SEO research. I am also active enough time here. So far, I have completed only 5 orders. Of course, I got 5 star reviews for each job.