Actually if you look at the WHOLE Criteria you will see that the Editorial Team DECIDE. They take into consideration the achievement criteria in their decision BUT (and this is what is subjective) - a seller can achieve ALL the Top Seller Criteria and still NOT be awarded Top Seller Status.
Top-Rated Seller
Important: This is a manual process. If you meet the Top-Rated requirements below, our Editorial team will review your performance from the previous 60 days to confirm your eligibility. After this, the Editorial team will decide if you're a Top-Rated Seller.
How do I know? Since November 2021 I achieved ALL the requirements below and expected to attain the Top Seller Status - yet when I enquired as to why I hadn't the Fiverr Team responded by saying it is an EDITOR decision. So why should a seller work hard to achieve the criteria when even the fiverr Team have zero influence over it award - that is why I made the decision to treat it as a joke and only focus on my customers.
This group of Sellers enjoys a growing number of exclusive benefits as they continue providing buyers with an overall excellent experience.
To reach Top-Rated Seller status, the following are required:
You have been an active seller for at least 180 days.
You have completed, at least, 100 orders (all time).
Your earnings are more than $20,000.
You have maintained a 4.7-star rating over 60 days.
Your response rate has received a score of 90% over 60 days.
Your order completion rate has received a score of 90% over 60 days.
Your on-time delivery score has received a score of 90% over 60 days.
You have received no warnings over 30 days.